At Redchilli Bikes, crank length is one of the choices we discuss before assembling your bike in Axminster, Devon.
Tell David how your current bike feels when you’re climbing seated or reaching for the drops. That helps us consider the cranks alongside your saddle position, cockpit and gearing, so the specification supports the way you ride.
A change of 5mm in cycling crank length can alter how freely you turn the pedals, how much room you have at the top of the stroke and how your whole riding position feels. Yet it is often treated as a fixed part of a groupset rather than a genuine fit choice. For many riders, it is not the biggest adjustment on a bike, but it can be a meaningful one when the rest of the position is already being considered carefully.
Most adult road bikes arrive with 170mm, 172.5mm or 175mm cranks. That convention is convenient for large-scale manufacture, not proof that one of those lengths is right for every rider. Crank choice should sit alongside frame size, saddle position, handlebar reach, gearing and the type of riding you want to do.
Why cycling crank length matters
A crank is a lever. A longer lever can produce more torque for a given force at the pedal, while a shorter lever travels through a smaller circle. In practice, the rider experience is more useful than the physics alone: longer cranks ask your hips, knees and ankles to move through a greater range; shorter cranks can make the pedal stroke feel more compact and less restricted at the top.
That difference is most noticeable when the rider is in a lower, more forward position. On a time-trial or triathlon bike, where the torso is rotated forwards and hip angle can become limited, a shorter crank may create useful space between the thigh and torso at the top of the pedal stroke. It can allow a rider to sustain an aerodynamic position with less feeling of being compressed.
On a road or endurance bike, the change may be subtler. A rider with limited hip mobility, recurring discomfort at the front of the hip, or knees that feel crowded near the top of the stroke may benefit from exploring a shorter option. Equally, a taller rider or someone who prefers a slower, more forceful pedalling style may feel perfectly at home on a longer crank. Neither outcome is automatic.
Crank length also affects saddle height. Moving from 172.5mm to 165mm cranks reduces the radius of the pedal circle by 7.5mm. Raising the saddle by approximately that amount is a starting point for preserving leg extension at the bottom of the stroke, followed by a check of how the rider moves. Reassess saddle setback and the relationship to the handlebars too. Raising the saddle increases the drop to unchanged bars, which can affect how easily you reach and hold them.
Longer or shorter cranks: the real trade-offs
The traditional assumption was simple: taller riders need longer cranks and shorter riders need shorter ones. Body proportions do matter, particularly leg length, but the relationship is not precise enough to prescribe a crank from height alone. Two riders of the same height may have very different femur lengths, ankle movement, flexibility, riding positions and pedalling preferences.
Longer cranks can offer a little more leverage, which some riders appreciate on steep climbs, in track events or when pushing a larger gear at lower cadence. However, the greater range of movement can also increase knee and hip flexion. On a bike with a low front end, it may make maintaining a comfortable position harder rather than easier.
Shorter cranks reduce that range. Many riders find they can turn the pedals smoothly at higher cadences and remain more relaxed through the hips. They can be particularly useful for smaller riders, but they are not only for smaller riders. A tall rider seeking a lower time-trial position may gain more from 165mm cranks than from 175mm, while a shorter rider who values leverage for a specific track discipline may prefer something longer than expected.
There is a gearing consideration too. A shorter crank provides marginally less leverage, but this is easily addressed by gearing and cadence rather than treated as a reason to avoid the change. If a rider moves to shorter cranks and finds a familiar climbing gear slightly heavier, a smaller chainring or a wider-range cassette may be the more useful answer. The bike should work as a complete system.
Start with position, not a number
The best crank length is rarely found by copying a professional rider or using an online height chart in isolation. Begin with what happens on your current bike.
Consider where you feel restricted or uncomfortable. Do your knees rise into your chest when riding on the drops? Does the front of the hip feel pinched on sustained climbs? Do you struggle to hold your time-trial position despite having reasonable flexibility? Or does the pedal stroke already feel natural, stable and powerful over long rides? These observations are more useful than chasing a fashionable number.
It is also worth separating a crank-length issue from other fit issues. A saddle that is too low, too far forward or poorly shaped can create knee discomfort. Bars that are too low or too far away can close the hip angle. Cleat position can influence how the foot and ankle behave through the stroke. Crank length may be part of the answer, but it should not be used to mask a position that needs attention elsewhere.
A considered fit assessment looks at the rider moving, not simply at static measurements. Pedalling technique, pelvic stability, ankle movement, cadence and the way a rider changes position under effort all matter. Comfort at an easy spin is useful, but the bike also needs to make sense halfway through a long sportive, on a steep Devon lane, or when holding threshold power into a headwind.
Road, gravel and endurance riding
When specifying a road or endurance build, we’d start by asking what crank length you currently ride and whether the pedal stroke feels comfortable throughout a long day. If it already works well, that is useful information. If you feel crowded at the top of the stroke, we’d consider crank length alongside saddle position and bar height before deciding what to change. A rider’s height alone gives us too little information to make that choice.
Gravel adds its own considerations. Pedal strikes are more likely off-road, especially on rough tracks, rutted lanes and technical climbs. A shorter crank slightly increases ground clearance at the bottom of the stroke. It is not a substitute for good line choice, but it can be a practical advantage on a bike built for mixed terrain.
Time trial and triathlon
This is where crank length often deserves closer attention. Lowering the torso can increase hip flexion at the top of the pedal stroke; saddle position and pelvic rotation also affect that relationship. Shorter cranks can create room to bring the torso lower without forcing the hip into an uncomfortable range.
That does not mean every time-triallist should immediately choose 155mm or 160mm cranks. The appropriate choice depends on the existing position, event duration, mobility, cadence preference and the rider’s ability to adapt. A modest move from 172.5mm to 165mm may be more useful and easier to accommodate than a dramatic change.
How to make a sensible change
If you are considering different cranks, avoid changing several major variables at once. Keep the same saddle and, where possible, the same cleat position. Reassess saddle height, setback and reach to the bars, then test the position on familiar routes. Before buying, also confirm compatibility with your bottom bracket, chainrings, drivetrain and any power meter you use.
The first ride can be misleading. A shorter crank can feel unusual simply because your timing is familiar with the old pedal circle. Give it several rides, including steady endurance work and the sort of climbing or hard efforts that matter to you. Look for a position that feels less constrained without losing stability or confidence.
It is also sensible to check gearing before committing. Riders who use a compact chainset and already spend long periods in their easiest gear may prefer to make a small gearing adjustment alongside a shorter crank. This is not a compromise. It is the practical detail that keeps the whole bike working as intended.
Choose Your Crank Length as Part of Your Redchilli Build
You can speak directly with David about the position and gearing you want from your next bike. Each Redchilli is individually specified and hand assembled in Devon, giving us the opportunity to consider crank length before the bike is built. Bring your current set-up into the conversation, along with what feels comfortable and what you’d like to improve.
Redchilli Bikes. Your Bike. Your Way.
